6 Comments

Very nicely articulated. I feel like I have had this debate myself several times.

Expand full comment

Hopefully you'll do one of these for your review of Caste!

Expand full comment
author

Haha yes! Definitely a good one to do!

Expand full comment
Aug 30Liked by Stetson

Yes, indeed! Provide more. I came here because of your reviews on GoodRead. I enjoy the reading comments, but I find them overwhelming (and often irritating). I would be happy to read the edited version. However, it would be good to see someone make a point that changes your mind or at least gives you pause. I am posting this in my Facebook "classroom"--where I share thoughtful essays and articles.

Expand full comment
author

Glad you find this interesting and thank you for sharing! I will do more, including trying to assemble example where there are meaningful adjustments in position based on the evidence presented.

Expand full comment

I think you characterize your debate style well, given what I recall from class!

Expand full comment